| | | Urbana wins the toss and will receive. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana35 | SHU ball on SHU30. |
| | | Steve Padilla kickoff 56 yards to the URBANA14, Troy Brookins return 13 yards to the URBANA27 (Bryan Osinski;Matt Galadyk). |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana27 | Nigel Smith rush for 4 yards to the URBANA31 (Darnell Jones;Matt Galadyk). |
| Urbana | 2-6 | at Urbana31 | Nigel Smith rush for 8 yards to the URBANA39, 1ST DOWN URBANA (D Alexander). |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana39 | Nigel Smith rush for loss of 1 yard to the URBANA38 (Matt Galadyk). |
| Urbana | 2-11 | at Urbana38 | David Gerber pass complete to Ian Iler for 30 yards to the SHU32, 1ST DOWN URBANA (Jeremy Haskins). |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu32 | Boise Moon rush for loss of 3 yards to the SHU35 (Matt Galadyk;Jeremy Haskins). |
| Urbana | 2-13 | at Shu35 | Boise Moon rush for 3 yards to the SHU32 (Tom Whalen). |
| Urbana | 3-10 | at Shu32 | David Gerber pass incomplete to Tar. Kalimullah (Ricky Cardwell). |
| Urbana | 4-10 | at Shu32 | David Gerber pass incomplete to Ian Iler. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 41 yards, TOP 03:06 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu32 | SETON HILL drive start at 11:54. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu32 | Antwarn Jones rush for 1 yard to the SHU33 (Drew Underwood;Chad Kinkead). |
| Shu | 2-9 | at Shu33 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Tyler Roby, dropped pass. |
| Shu | 3-9 | at Shu33 | Timeout Seton Hill, clock 11:13. |
| Shu | 3-9 | at Shu33 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Antwarn Jones for 27 yards to the URBANA40, 1ST DOWN SHU (Murl Johnson). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Urbana40 | Antwarn Jones rush for 10 yards to the URBANA30, 1ST DOWN SHU (Joshua Turnbo). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Urbana30 | Nick Monteleone rush for 15 yards to the URBANA15, 1ST DOWN SHU, out-of-bounds (Murl Johnson). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Urbana15 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Zach Delo (Travis Brisco). |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Urbana15 | Antwarn Jones rush for 15 yards to the URBANA0, 1ST DOWN SHU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:31. |
| | | Steve Padilla kick attempt good. |
| | | Seton Hill 7, Urbana (OH) 0 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 68 yards, TOP 02:23 |
| | | Steve Padilla kickoff 63 yards to the URBANA2, Troy Brookins return 23 yards to the URBANA25 (Bryan Osinski;Eric Farmer). |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana25 | URBANA (OH) drive start at 09:24. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana25 | Nigel Smith rush for loss of 1 yard to the URBANA24 (Rodney McMath). |
| Urbana | 2-11 | at Urbana24 | David Gerber pass incomplete to Ian Iler. |
| Urbana | 3-11 | at Urbana24 | David Gerber rush for loss of 3 yards to the URBANA21 (Matt Galadyk;Chris Galadyk). |
| Urbana | 4-14 | at Urbana21 | John McCoy punt 39 yards to the SHU40, fair catch by Jonathan Feagin, PENALTY URBANA kick catching interference 15 yards to the URBANA45, 1st and 10, SHU ball on URBANA45. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 01:23 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Urbana45 | SETON HILL drive start at 08:01. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Urbana45 | Antwarn Jones rush for loss of 1 yard to the URBANA46 (Aaron Irby). |
| Shu | 2-11 | at Urbana46 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Zach Delo for 6 yards to the URBANA40 (Chad Kinkead;Jerrod Slater). |
| Shu | 3-5 | at Urbana40 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Dorian Scott for 7 yards to the URBANA33, 1ST DOWN SHU (Daniel Goodrum). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Urbana33 | Tyler Roby rush for loss of 9 yards to the URBANA42, out-of-bounds (Travis Brisco). |
| Shu | 2-19 | at Urbana42 | Antwarn Jones rush for 4 yards to the URBANA38 (Chad Kinkead;Bret Kinkead). |
| Shu | 3-15 | at Urbana38 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Tyler Roby for 13 yards to the URBANA25 (Traylin Taylor). |
| Shu | 4-2 | at Urbana25 | PENALTY SHU false start 5 yards to the URBANA30. |
| Shu | 4-7 | at Urbana30 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Dorian Scott. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 15 yards, TOP 04:02 |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana30 | URBANA (OH) drive start at 03:59. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana30 | Nigel Smith rush for 10 yards to the URBANA40, 1ST DOWN URBANA (D Alexander;Ricky Cardwell). |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana40 | David Gerber pass incomplete to Ian Iler, dropped pass. |
| Urbana | 2-10 | at Urbana40 | Nigel Smith rush for 1 yard to the URBANA41 (Rodney McMath). |
| Urbana | 3-9 | at Urbana41 | David Gerber pass complete to Tar. Kalimullah for 30 yards to the SHU29, 1ST DOWN URBANA (Jonathan Feagin). |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu29 | Nigel Smith rush for 1 yard to the SHU28 (Matt Galadyk;Darnell Jones). |
| Urbana | 2-9 | at Shu28 | David Gerber pass incomplete to Tar. Kalimullah (D Alexander). |
| Urbana | 3-9 | at Shu28 | PENALTY URBANA false start 5 yards to the SHU33. |
| Urbana | 3-14 | at Shu33 | David Gerber pass intercepted by Jonathan Feagin at the SHU0, Jonathan Feagin return 0 yards to the SHU0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 37 yards, TOP 02:18 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu20 | SETON HILL drive start at 01:41. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu20 | PENALTY SHU delay of game 5 yards to the SHU15. |
| Shu | 1-15 | at Shu15 | Nick Monteleone rush for loss of 5 yards to the SHU10, fumble forced by Chad Kinkead, fumble by Nick Monteleone recovered by URBANA Shawn Lewis at SHU10. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 10 yards, TOP 00:07 |
| Urbana | 1-G | at Shu10 | URBANA (OH) drive start at 01:34. |
| Urbana | 1-G | at Shu10 | Nigel Smith rush for 9 yards to the SHU1 (D Alexander). |
| Urbana | 2-G | at Shu01 | Nigel Smith rush for no gain to the SHU1 (Tom Whalen;Matt Christiani). |
| Urbana | 3-G | at Shu01 | David Gerber rush for no gain to the SHU1 (Tom Whalen;Steve Trent). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 01:39 |
| | | Seton Hill 7, Urbana (OH) 0 |
| Urbana | 4-G | at Shu01 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Urbana | 4-G | at Shu01 | Ian Iler rush for no gain to the SHU1 (Rodney McMath). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 9 yards, TOP 01:39 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu01 | SETON HILL drive start at 14:55. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu01 | PENALTY URBANA offside 5 yards to the SHU6. |
| Shu | 1-5 | at Shu06 | RJ Butler rush for 3 yards to the SHU9 (Travis Brisco;Shawn Lewis). |
| Shu | 2-2 | at Shu09 | RJ Butler rush for 1 yard to the SHU10 (Chad Kinkead;Shawn Lewis). |
| Shu | 3-1 | at Shu10 | RJ Butler rush for no gain to the SHU10 (Travis Brisco). |
| Shu | 4-1 | at Shu10 | Bryce Ogilbee punt 29 yards to the SHU39, fair catch by Troy Brookins. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 02:09 |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu39 | URBANA (OH) drive start at 12:46. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu39 | Nigel Smith rush for 1 yard to the SHU38 (Calvin Mason), PENALTY SHU unsportsmanlike conduct 15 yards to the SHU23, 1ST DOWN URBANA. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu23 | 1st and 10. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu23 | Nigel Smith rush for 16 yards to the SHU7, 1ST DOWN URBANA (Ricky Cardwell). |
| Urbana | 1-G | at Shu07 | David Gerber pass complete to Jerrell Leak for 6 yards to the SHU1 (Ricky Cardwell;Jeremy Haskins). |
| Urbana | 2-G | at Shu01 | David Gerber rush for no gain to the SHU1 (Darnell Jones). |
| Urbana | 3-G | at Shu01 | Nigel Smith rush for no gain to the SHU1 (Rodney McMath). |
| Urbana | 4-G | at Shu01 | Ian Iler rush for no gain to the SHU1 (Rodney McMath;Calvin Mason). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 38 yards, TOP 03:11 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu01 | SETON HILL drive start at 09:35. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu01 | Antwarn Jones rush for no gain to the SHU1 (Justin Burum;Travis Brisco). |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Shu01 | Antwarn Jones rush for 3 yards to the SHU4 (Drew Underwood). |
| Shu | 3-7 | at Shu04 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Anth Armstead. |
| Shu | 4-7 | at Shu04 | Bryce Ogilbee punt 32 yards to the SHU36, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 01:22 |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu36 | URBANA (OH) drive start at 08:13. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu36 | David Gerber pass incomplete to Jerrell Leak. |
| Urbana | 2-10 | at Shu36 | David Gerber pass complete to Ian Iler for 12 yards to the SHU24, 1ST DOWN URBANA (D Alexander). |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu24 | David Gerber pass complete to Jerrell Leak for 14 yards to the SHU10, 1ST DOWN URBANA (Steve Trent;D Alexander). |
| Urbana | 1-G | at Shu10 | David Gerber pass complete to Jerrell Leak for 2 yards to the SHU8 (Matt Galadyk), PENALTY URBANA holding 10 yards to the SHU18. |
| Urbana | 1-G | at Shu18 | 1st and 18. |
| Urbana | 1-G | at Shu18 | David Gerber pass complete to Jerrell Leak for 17 yards to the SHU1 (Calvin Mason). |
| Urbana | 2-G | at Shu01 | David Gerber pass complete to Ian Iler for no gain to the SHU1 (Jeremy Haskins). |
| Urbana | 3-G | at Shu01 | David Gerber pass incomplete to Jerrell Leak. |
| Urbana | 4-G | at Shu01 | Ian Iler rush for 1 yard to the SHU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:00. |
| | | Matt Hausheer kick attempt good. |
| | | Urbana (OH) 7, Seton Hill 7 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 36 yards, TOP 02:13 |
| | | Matt Hausheer kickoff 56 yards to the SHU9, D Alexander return 25 yards to the SHU34 (Shane Cahill). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu34 | SETON HILL drive start at 05:52. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu34 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Samuel Tranks for 6 yards to the SHU40 (Chad Kinkead;Wes Edwards). |
| Shu | 2-4 | at Shu40 | PENALTY URBANA offside 5 yards to the SHU45, 1ST DOWN SHU. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu45 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Samuel Tranks. |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Shu45 | Antwarn Jones rush for 3 yards to the SHU48 (Chad Kinkead). |
| Shu | 3-7 | at Shu48 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Dorian Scott for 4 yards to the URBANA48 (Daniel Goodrum). |
| Shu | 4-3 | at Urbana48 | Bryce Ogilbee punt 35 yards to the URBANA13, Troy Brookins return to the URBANA13, fumble forced by Sean Randall, fumble by Troy Brookins recovered by SHU Daniel Butler at URBANA13, PENALTY SHU personal foul 16 yards to the SHU36, NO PLAY. |
| Shu | 4-19 | at Shu36 | Bryce Ogilbee punt 27 yards to the URBANA37, downed. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 2 yards, TOP 02:20 |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana37 | URBANA (OH) drive start at 03:32. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana37 | Drew Parker sacked for loss of 11 yards to the URBANA26 (Steve Trent;Matt Galadyk). |
| Urbana | 2-21 | at Urbana26 | Ian Iler rush for 2 yards to the URBANA28 (Rodney McMath). |
| Urbana | 3-19 | at Urbana28 | Timeout Seton Hill, clock 02:33. |
| Urbana | 3-19 | at Urbana28 | Ian Iler rush for loss of 6 yards to the URBANA22, fumble by Ian Iler recovered by URBANA Ian Iler at URBANA22. |
| Urbana | 4-25 | at Urbana22 | Timeout Seton Hill, clock 02:28. |
| Urbana | 4-25 | at Urbana22 | John McCoy punt 36 yards to the SHU42, D Alexander return 1 yards to the SHU43 (Boise Moon;Brandon Iler). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 15 yards, TOP 01:16 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu43 | SETON HILL drive start at 02:16. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu43 | Nick Monteleone rush for 8 yards to the URBANA49 (Chad Kinkead). |
| Shu | 2-2 | at Urbana49 | Nick Monteleone pass intercepted by Daniel Goodrum at the URBANA43, Daniel Goodrum return 57 yards to the SHU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:35. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 8 yards, TOP 00:41 |
| | | Matt Hausheer kick attempt good. |
| | | Urbana (OH) 14, Seton Hill 7 |
| | | Matt Hausheer kickoff 56 yards to the SHU9, D Alexander return 29 yards to the SHU38 (Joshua Turnbo). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu38 | SETON HILL drive start at 01:28. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu38 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Antwarn Jones for 2 yards to the SHU40 (Wes Edwards). |
| Shu | 2-8 | at Shu40 | Nick Monteleone rush for loss of 2 yards to the SHU38, fumble forced by Travis Brisco, fumble by Nick Monteleone recovered by SHU Nick Monteleone at SHU38, Nick Monteleone for 11 yards to the SHU49, 1ST DOWN SHU (Daniel Goodrum). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu49 | Nick Monteleone rush for 1 yard to the 50 yardline (Chad Kinkead), PENALTY SHU personal foul 15 yards to the SHU35. |
| Shu | 1-24 | at Shu35 | 2nd and 24. |
| Shu | 2-24 | at Shu35 | PENALTY SHU offside 5 yards to the SHU30. |
| Shu | 2-29 | at Shu30 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Antwarn Jones for 9 yards to the SHU39 (Chad Kinkead). |
| Shu | 3-20 | at Shu39 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Antwarn Jones (Shawn Lewis). |
| Shu | 4-20 | at Shu39 | Bryce Ogilbee punt 35 yards to the URBANA26, Troy Brookins return 0 yards to the URBANA26 (Sean Randall). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:04 |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana26 | URBANA (OH) drive start at 00:24. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana26 | TEAM rush for loss of 2 yards to the URBANA24. |
| Urbana | 2-12 | at Urbana24 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 00:24 |
| | | Urbana (OH) 14, Seton Hill 7 |
| Urbana | 2-12 | at Urbana24 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, URBANA ball on URBANA30. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 00:24 |
| | | Matt Hausheer kickoff 55 yards to the SHU15, Samuel Tranks return 21 yards to the SHU36, fumble forced by Drew Underwood, fumble by Samuel Tranks recovered by URBANA Juan McKeever at SHU36. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu36 | URBANA (OH) drive start at 14:53. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu36 | Ian Iler rush for 6 yards to the SHU30 (Corey Perkins). |
| Urbana | 2-4 | at Shu30 | Nigel Smith rush for no gain to the SHU30 (Darnell Jones;Chris Galadyk). |
| Urbana | 3-4 | at Shu30 | Boise Moon rush for 3 yards to the SHU27 (Darnell Jones). |
| Urbana | 4-1 | at Shu27 | Boise Moon rush for 8 yards to the SHU19, 1ST DOWN URBANA (Corey Perkins). |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu19 | Ian Iler rush for 9 yards to the SHU10 (Ricky Cardwell). |
| Urbana | 2-1 | at Shu10 | Boise Moon rush for loss of 1 yard to the SHU11 (Anthony DiPerna). |
| Urbana | 3-2 | at Shu11 | Ian Iler rush for no gain to the SHU11 (Matt Galadyk;Corey Perkins). |
| Urbana | 4-2 | at Shu11 | Matt Hausheer field goal attempt from 28 GOOD, clock 10:48. |
| | | Urbana (OH) 17, Seton Hill 7 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 25 yards, TOP 04:05 |
| | | Matt Hausheer kickoff 55 yards to the SHU10, Samuel Tranks return 22 yards to the SHU32 (Boise Moon). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu32 | SETON HILL drive start at 10:39. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu32 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Zach Delo for 18 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN SHU (Wes Edwards). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu50 | Antwarn Jones rush for 3 yards to the URBANA47 (Chad Kinkead;Wes Edwards). |
| Shu | 2-7 | at Urbana47 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Dorian Scott for 15 yards to the URBANA32, 1ST DOWN SHU (Troy Brookins). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Urbana32 | Nick Monteleone sacked for loss of 2 yards to the URBANA34 (Murl Johnson;Shawn Lewis). |
| Shu | 2-12 | at Urbana34 | Antwarn Jones rush for 5 yards to the URBANA29 (Chad Kinkead). |
| Shu | 3-7 | at Urbana29 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Samuel Tranks. |
| Shu | 4-7 | at Urbana29 | Steve Padilla field goal attempt from 46 MISSED - wide left, spot at URBANA29, clock 08:00. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 39 yards, TOP 06:15 |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana29 | Nigel Smith rush for 5 yards to the URBANA34 (Corey Perkins;Chris Galadyk). |
| Urbana | 2-5 | at Urbana34 | Ian Iler rush for 2 yards to the URBANA36 (Rodney McMath;Steve Trent). |
| Urbana | 3-3 | at Urbana36 | Timeout Urbana (OH), clock 06:26. |
| Urbana | 3-3 | at Urbana36 | Ian Iler rush for 5 yards to the URBANA41, 1ST DOWN URBANA (Corey Perkins;Rodney McMath). |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana41 | Nigel Smith rush for loss of 4 yards to the URBANA37 (Corey Perkins). |
| Urbana | 2-14 | at Urbana37 | Drew Parker pass incomplete to Jerrell Leak (D Alexander). |
| Urbana | 3-14 | at Urbana37 | Ian Iler rush for 1 yard to the URBANA38 (Matt Galadyk). |
| Urbana | 4-13 | at Urbana38 | John McCoy punt 31 yards to the SHU31, fair catch by Daniel Butler. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 9 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu31 | SETON HILL drive start at 04:24. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu31 | Antwarn Jones rush for loss of 2 yards to the SHU29 (Troy Brookins). |
| Shu | 2-12 | at Shu29 | Antwarn Jones rush for loss of 1 yard to the SHU28 (Trey White). |
| Shu | 3-13 | at Shu28 | PENALTY SHU false start 5 yards to the SHU23. |
| Shu | 3-18 | at Shu23 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Sean Randall for 12 yards to the SHU35, fumble forced by Shawn Lewis, fumble by Sean Randall recovered by URBANA Chad Kinkead at SHU32. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:39 |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu32 | URBANA (OH) drive start at 02:45. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu32 | Ian Iler rush for 5 yards to the SHU27 (Calvin Mason). |
| Urbana | 2-5 | at Shu27 | Ian Iler rush for 8 yards to the SHU19, 1ST DOWN URBANA (Corey Perkins;Steve Trent). |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu19 | Nigel Smith rush for 8 yards to the SHU11 (Corey Perkins;Ricky Cardwell). |
| Urbana | 2-2 | at Shu11 | Ian Iler rush for 7 yards to the SHU4, 1ST DOWN URBANA (D Alexander;Steve Trent). |
| Urbana | 1-G | at Shu04 | Ian Iler rush for 4 yards to the SHU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:29. |
| | | Matt Hausheer kick attempt good. |
| | | Urbana (OH) 24, Seton Hill 7 |
| | | Matt Hausheer kickoff 56 yards to the SHU9, D Alexander return to the SHU25 (Shane Cahill), PENALTY URBANA offside 5 yards to the URBANA30, NO PLAY. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 32 yards, TOP 02:16 |
| | | Matt Hausheer kickoff 56 yards to the SHU14, D Alexander return 34 yards to the SHU48 (Shane Cahill). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu48 | SETON HILL drive start at 00:15. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu48 | Nick Monteleone rush for 1 yard to the SHU49 (Wes Edwards), PENALTY SHU holding 10 yards to the SHU39. |
| Shu | 1-19 | at Shu39 | 1st and 19. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 9 yards, TOP 04:20 |
| | | Urbana (OH) 24, Seton Hill 7 |
| Shu | 1-19 | at Shu39 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Shu | 1-19 | at Shu39 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Dorian Scott for 13 yards to the URBANA48 (Wes Edwards). |
| Shu | 2-6 | at Urbana48 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Clayton Shaver for 22 yards to the URBANA26, 1ST DOWN SHU (Troy Brookins). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Urbana26 | Timeout Seton Hill, clock 14:07. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Urbana26 | PENALTY SHU false start 5 yards to the URBANA31. |
| Shu | 1-15 | at Urbana31 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Samuel Tranks (Jerrod Slater). |
| Shu | 2-15 | at Urbana31 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Zach Delo. |
| Shu | 3-15 | at Urbana31 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Antwarn Jones for loss of 1 yard to the URBANA32 (Murl Johnson). |
| Shu | 4-16 | at Urbana32 | Nick Monteleone sacked for loss of 6 yards to the URBANA38 (Travis Brisco), PENALTY URBANA personal foul 15 yards to the URBANA17, 1ST DOWN SHU, NO PLAY. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Urbana17 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Samuel Tranks for 5 yards to the URBANA12 (Wes Edwards;Daniel Goodrum). |
| Shu | 2-5 | at Urbana12 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Antwarn Jones for loss of 4 yards to the URBANA16 (Daniel Goodrum). |
| Shu | 3-9 | at Urbana16 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Tyler Roby for 12 yards to the URBANA4, 1ST DOWN SHU (Joshua Turnbo). |
| Shu | 1-G | at Urbana04 | Antwarn Jones rush for 4 yards to the URBANA0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:55. |
| | | Steve Padilla kick attempt good. |
| | | Urbana (OH) 24, Seton Hill 14 |
| Shu | 1-G | at Shu35 | PENALTY SHU personal foul 15 yards to the SHU20. |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 52 yards, TOP 04:20 |
| | | Steve Padilla kickoff 31 yards to the URBANA49, fair catch by Daniel Goodrum. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana49 | URBANA (OH) drive start at 10:55. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana49 | Nigel Smith rush for 2 yards to the SHU49 (Steve Trent;Darnell Jones). |
| Urbana | 2-8 | at Shu49 | Ian Iler rush for loss of 2 yards to the URBANA49 (Calvin Mason). |
| Urbana | 3-10 | at Urbana49 | Drew Parker pass incomplete to Ian Iler. |
| Urbana | 4-10 | at Urbana49 | PENALTY URBANA false start 5 yards to the URBANA44. |
| Urbana | 4-15 | at Urbana44 | John McCoy punt 44 yards to the SHU12, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 5 yards, TOP 01:40 |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu12 | SETON HILL drive start at 09:15. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu12 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to RJ Butler for 14 yards to the SHU26, 1ST DOWN SHU (Chad Kinkead). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu26 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Dorian Scott for 13 yards to the SHU39, 1ST DOWN SHU (Troy Brookins). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu39 | Nick Monteleone rush for 11 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN SHU (Chad Kinkead). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu50 | Nick Monteleone sacked for loss of 7 yards to the SHU43 (Travis Brisco). |
| Shu | 2-17 | at Shu43 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Samuel Tranks. |
| Shu | 3-17 | at Shu43 | RJ Butler rush for 11 yards to the URBANA46 (Wes Edwards). |
| Shu | 4-6 | at Urbana46 | Timeout Urbana (OH), clock 07:02. |
| Shu | 4-6 | at Urbana46 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Dorian Scott for 11 yards to the URBANA35, 1ST DOWN SHU (Wes Edwards). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Urbana35 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Samuel Tranks. |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Urbana35 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to RJ Butler for loss of 7 yards to the URBANA42 (Chad Kinkead). |
| Shu | 3-17 | at Urbana42 | PENALTY SHU false start 5 yards to the URBANA47. |
| Shu | 3-22 | at Urbana47 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Tyler Roby for 24 yards to the URBANA23, 1ST DOWN SHU (Travis Brisco). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Urbana23 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Tyler Roby (Joshua Turnbo). |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Urbana23 | RJ Butler rush for 3 yards to the URBANA20 (Justin Burum;Traylin Taylor). |
| Shu | 3-7 | at Urbana20 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Tyler Roby. |
| Shu | 4-7 | at Urbana20 | Steve Padilla field goal attempt from 37 BLOCKED, recovered by URBANA Jerrod Slater at URBANA20 spot at URBANA20, clock 04:00 (blocked by Wes Edwards), Jerrod Slater for 57 yards to the SHU23 (Steve Padilla). |
| | | Drive: 14 plays, 68 yards, TOP 06:59 |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Shu23 | Ian Iler rush for 19 yards to the SHU4, 1ST DOWN URBANA (Ricky Cardwell). |
| Urbana | 1-G | at Shu04 | Ian Iler rush for 2 yards to the SHU2 (Steve Trent). |
| Urbana | 2-G | at Shu02 | Ian Iler rush for 1 yard to the SHU1 (Darnell Jones). |
| Urbana | 3-G | at Shu01 | Timeout Seton Hill, clock 02:21. |
| Urbana | 3-G | at Shu01 | Ian Iler rush for 1 yard to the SHU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:16. |
| | | Matt Hausheer kick attempt failed (blocked), returned by Corey Perkins - no score (blocked by TEAM) (blocked by Rob Ellis). |
| | | Urbana (OH) 30, Seton Hill 14 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 23 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Matt Hausheer kickoff 52 yards to the SHU13, D Alexander return 26 yards to the SHU39 (Daniel Goodrum). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu39 | SETON HILL drive start at 02:07. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu39 | Timeout Urbana (OH), clock 02:07. |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Shu39 | Antwarn Jones rush for 12 yards to the URBANA49, 1ST DOWN SHU (Daniel Goodrum). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Urbana49 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Antwarn Jones for 6 yards to the URBANA43, out-of-bounds (Chad Kinkead). |
| Shu | 2-4 | at Urbana43 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Dorian Scott. |
| Shu | 3-4 | at Urbana43 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Samuel Tranks for 6 yards to the URBANA37, 1ST DOWN SHU (Shane Cahill). |
| Shu | 1-10 | at Urbana37 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Tyler Roby. |
| Shu | 2-10 | at Urbana37 | Nick Monteleone pass complete to Tyler Roby for 7 yards to the URBANA30 (Wes Edwards). |
| Shu | 3-3 | at Urbana30 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Antwarn Jones. |
| Shu | 4-3 | at Urbana30 | Nick Monteleone pass incomplete to Tyler Roby, dropped pass. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 31 yards, TOP 01:20 |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana30 | URBANA (OH) drive start at 00:47. |
| Urbana | 1-10 | at Urbana30 | TEAM rush for loss of 2 yards to the URBANA28. |
| Urbana | 2-12 | at Urbana28 | TEAM rush for loss of 2 yards to the URBANA26. |
| Urbana | 3-14 | at Urbana26 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 00:47 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Urbana (OH) 30, Seton Hill 14 |