1996:
Slippery Rock 5, WV Wesleyan 2
Shippensburg 3, WV Wesleyan 2
Shippensburg 8, Slippery Rock 7 (14 innings)
Slippery Rock 12, Shippensburg 6
Shippensburg 9, Slippery Rock 6 (championship)

1997:
Mansfield 6, Slippery Rock 1
Slippery Rock 5, Shepherd 4
Shepherd 10, Mansfield 9
Shepherd 6, Mansfield 3
Slippery Rock 18, Shepherd 2 (championship)

1998:
WV State 7, Slippery Rock 6
Millersville 4, West Liberty 1
West Liberty 9, Slippery Rock 3
Millersville 9, WV State 7
WV State 15, West Liberty 7
WV State 13, Millersville 3
Millersville 5, WV State 0 (championship)

1999:
WV State 13, Slippery Rock 11
Shippensburg 11, Kutztown 8
Kutztown 12, Slippery Rock 10
WV State 16, Shippensburg 10
Shippensburg 10, Kutztown 8
WV State 12, Shippensburg 6 (championship)

2000:
Millersville 4, Shippensburg 2 (10 innings)
Slippery Rock 10, WV State 6
Shippensburg 4, WV State 3
Slippery Rock 10, Millersville 2
Millersville 13, Shippensburg 6
Slippery Rock 4, Millersville 2 (championship)

2001:
Slippery Rock 5, WV State 1
Kutztown 9, Concord 8
WV State 6, Concord 2
Kutztown 5, Slippery Rock 3
Slippery Rock 8, WV State 4
Slippery Rock 8, Kutztown 1
Kutztown 6, Slippery Rock 2 (championship)

2002:
Mansfield 8, WV State 4 (10 innings)
Kutztown 4, Shepherd 2
Shepherd 8, WV State 6
Kutztown 3, Mansfield 2
Shepherd 11, Mansfield 5
Shepherd 6, Kutztown 0
Kutztown 12, Shepherd 3 (championship)

2003:
Shippensburg 4, West Chester 0
Slippery Rock 3, Kutztown 1
Kutztown 3, West Chester 0
Shippensburg 2, Slippery Rock 1
Slippery Rock 2, Kutztown 1
Slippery Rock 10, Shippensburg 1
Slippery Rock 7, Shippensburg 5 (championship)

2004:
Kutztown 13, WV State 2
Shippensburg 2, West Chester 1
WV State 9, West Chester 8
Kutztown 2, Shippensburg 1 (10 innnings)
WV State 9, Shippensburg 6
Kutztown 6, WV State 4 (10 innings, championship)

2005:
West Chester 9, Kutztown 1
WV State 14, Slippery Rock 3
Kutztown 5, Slippery Rock 4
WV State 3, West Chester 2
West Chester 13, Kutztown 2
WV State 9, West Chester 2 (championship)

2006:
WV State 13, Pitt Johnstown 1
Kutztown 7, Ohio Valley 0
West Chester 9, Shepherd 5
Ohio Valley 2, Pitt Johnstown 1
WV State 18, Shepherd 5
West Chester 5, Kutztown 1
West Chester 9, WV State 4
Kutztown 10, Ohio Valley 3
Kutztown 15, WV State 11
Kutztown 7, West Chester 4
West Chester 14, Kutztown 3 (championship)

2007:
Kutztown 4, Shippensburg 3
West Chester 2, WV State 0
Slippery Rock 6, California (PA) 3
Shippensburg 6, WV State 1
Kutztown 6, California (PA) 1
Slippery Rock 6, West Chester 5 (10 innings)
Kutztown 7, Slippery Rock 3
West Chester 7, Shippensburg 4
West Chester 11, Slippery Rock 10 (10 innings)
Kutztown 9, West Chester 1 (championship)